Comment: 70 years of the Edinburgh Festival Published on: 7 August 2017 Writing for The Conversation, Dr Adam Behr discusses what the Edinburgh festival has done for the arts - and economy. , co-founder and first director of the Edinburgh International Festival, once said: 鈥淭he opera always loses money. That鈥檚 as it should be. Opera has no business making money.鈥� Clearly this didn鈥檛 hinder his career, as he went on to be manager of New York鈥檚 Metropolitan Opera for 22 years. It was a throwaway comment, perhaps, though Bing was noted less for flippancy than an abiding commitment to the and music in particular. It鈥檚 hard to know what he would make of today鈥檚 of Edinburgh festivals, with an artistic and financial range expanded so far beyond the scope of the original that it prompted one audience member to : The Edinburgh Festival obliterates the city: there isn鈥檛 a town called Edinburgh any more, there鈥檚 a town called the Edinburgh Festival. And you can鈥檛 escape it. That鈥檚 perhaps overstating the case 鈥� there are geographical and demographic parts of Edinburgh beyond the core of the Festival 鈥� but only slightly. There鈥檚 no doubting its centrality to both the city鈥檚 profile and its economy. Indeed, Edinburgh has become synonymous with its festivals in the since the International Festival was launched by Bing. And although much of the stand-up comedy and commercial content would probably be anathema to him, it鈥檚 also the case that while its festivals have shaped Edinburgh, it was the city鈥檚 features that drew them there in the first place. Post-war progress It鈥檚 possible to view the growth of the Edinburgh International and Fringe Festivals through the prism of post-war historical and political progress. Rudolph Bing himself arrived in Britain having fled Nazi Germany in 1934. The first Edinburgh Festival was explicitly of as an attempt to bring people together after the Second World War, but in the knowledge that many of Europe鈥檚 major cities were too devastated by the fighting to be able to host such an event. Bing looked at other cities, including Oxford, but arrived at Edinburgh on the grounds that it not only had the scale to be able to support such an undertaking, but had also maintained its pre-war elegance, being relatively unscathed by the extensive bombing that had shattered many other major cities. In this respect, there are historical parallels with the use of the arts as a part of the process of social recovery after the war. The , forerunner of the modern Arts Councils, emerged from the , which had itself been set up in 1939 to boost morale and provide employment to artists during the war. Gaining its first Royal Charter in 1946, the Arts Council of Great Britain was inspired by a continuing desire to uplift society, and also to sustain art forms that had suffered or been co-opted by totalitarian propaganda during the war years, such as with the fascists鈥� use of Beethoven, Wagner and others. It initially operated under the auspices of , the economist whose ideas helped to shape much government policy from the 1940s to the 1970s, and can be seen as a part of the . Indeed, Bing co-founded the Festival with , chair of the , set up prior to the war to use British culture to promote cooperation and education. High and popular culture The emphasis on culture at this point was very much on the 鈥渉igh鈥� arts, yet from its inception, the festival has been a focal point for debates about culture and who, precisely, it is for. emerged at the same time as the International Festival when theatre companies that hadn鈥檛 been invited to the official festival turned up regardless and occupied alternative venues. Also feeding into fringe activities was the , launched by poet in 1951 with backing from the Labour Party, Communist Party and Edinburgh Trades Union Council. This was a reaction against the perceived elitism of the International Festival where the emphasis on opera and high art was seen as excluding both working people and, crucially, the local culture of the city in which it was based. While this sought to place traditional, and Scottish, arts at the centre of the festival experience, the broader range of the Fringe as it has grown alongside the International Festival has seen the inclusion of experimental and, notably, commercial culture. From in 1960, featuring Jonathan Miller, Alan Bennett, Peter Cook and Dudley Moore, the Fringe has been closely aligned with the forefront of popular comedy, as evidenced by the extensive sponsorship of comedy awards associated with it. In spite of the that most shows and many venues encounter in turning a profit, there鈥檚 no question about the economic scale of both the International and Fringe Festivals, counter to 鈥� somewhat ironically 鈥� the core values of both Bing and the members of the Labour movement behind the Peoples鈥� Festival. The International and Fringe Festivals have given rise to a year-round calendar of events that in 2015 was to the city鈥檚 economy and 拢313m nationally. Indeed, the festivals are now so important to Edinburgh鈥檚 identity and economy that they have become part of about how to manage the cultural provision for the city as a whole, and outside of the festival period. Concerns have been raised, with one promoter : The support mechanisms required to support grassroots and small-scale cultural activity in Edinburgh outside the Festival and [the New Year celebration in Scotland] periods are simply not there. Debates about how to manage city life, and the relationship between the Edinburgh Festivals and the rest of the city are unlikely to go away. Likewise, the question of whether the arts should be valued for rarefied excellence, as per Bing鈥檚 perspective, or their social inclusion, as Henderson believed, will long be with us. But regardless of whether we view culture as an intrinsic good in itself or for the instrumental benefits it brings, there鈥檚 no question that they are increasingly an at local and national levels. And for Edinburgh, while the festivals may have diverged considerably from Rudolph Bing鈥檚 initial artistic vision, the core notion of bringing people together to celebrate the arts, however the word is defined, has put Scotland鈥檚 capital on the map. , Lecturer in Popular and Contemporary Music, This article was originally published on . Read the . Share: Latest News 缅北禁地 expert highlights climate crisis in a new film A leading 缅北禁地 climate scientist is featured in a new film about how the climate and nature breakdown will affect the UK. published on: 14 April 2026 Neolithic tombs reveal ancient kinship ties Male individuals buried in Neolithic chambered tombs in northern Scotland were often related to each other through the paternal line and some were interred in the same or nearby tombs, research shows. published on: 14 April 2026 We are our Memories New exhibition by Fine Art graduate Trish Hudson-Moses, 22 April 鈥� 4 May 2026 published on: 10 April 2026 Facts and figures
![缅北禁地 logo](/gomobileassets/img/logo.svg" "缅北禁地"){kind=logo}