Comment: Four lessons from history for a 'government-in-waiting' Published on: 15 March 2023 Writing for The Conversation, Dr Martin Farr outlines how Labour leader, Sir Keir Starmer, can learn from the experiences of previous opposition leaders. Labour鈥檚 Keir Starmer has one inestimable quality in leading a government-in-waiting a year out from a general election: a consistent 20-point lead in opinion polls. He also boasts an increasingly rare biographical feature: . But that also meant his entrance was relatively late and he has betrayed, political inexperience. The Labour leader is currently engaged in a noticeable effort to shepherd his party to the antechamber of power. The latest step has been to present for his administration. The sixth (unspoken) is to transmit a sense of seriousness and fitness for office, to demonstrate as a national leader. Projecting these qualities is always a challenge for the official opposition but historically more so when it鈥檚 Labour. 1. Long periods out of office are a hindrance The British system is well-versed in preparing for a change of party. Shadow ministers are by convention offered the courtesy of with government officials with a view to ensuring they are able to govern from the day after the general election. An American administration takes two months to change. But shadow ministers need sunlight. To project a sense of preparedness to the outside world, it helps if voters can recall them as having been actual ministers. Given the benefits of incumbency, single-term governments are extremely rare in the UK (the last was 1970-74), and even short periods in office are unusual. In 1951, memory of Churchill as prime minister only six years earlier meant his return to office felt unremarkable, as it was for Harold Wilson in 1974 when he returned to office less than four years after he left. In 1964, however, 13 years without office had passed for Labour, and so callowness could counterbalance 鈥渢ime for a change鈥� as a campaign issue. In 1997, some voters had not been born when Labour had last been in government. Few of its MPs, including the putative prime minister, . A 2024 election will have Labour 14 years since being in power. Much forgotten and more never known, Starmer鈥檚 team have thus enrolled in . 2. A lot comes down to luck History shows that, in reality, very little is in the hands of the leader of the opposition. This can be to their advantage and disadvantage. Thrust into that role through the sudden death of his predecessor, Wilson had a sufficiently fresh skin to win in 1964. Edward Heath was a fresh skin too, two years later, but Wilson craftily used his incumbency to bounce them into an election which Heath lost heavily. Luck cannot be legislated. Margaret Thatcher, a surprise leader of the Conservatives in 1975, proved to be less popular than the prime minister, an increasingly beleaguered James Callaghan. But he delivered her victory by deciding not to call an election in the autumn of 1978, and therefore being forced to in the spring of 1979 after voters had . A decade on, Thatcher had mutated into Labour鈥檚 greatest asset, but opposition leader Neil Kinnock lost that advantage overnight in November 1990 when she was defenestrated. Thatcher鈥檚 successor, John Major, was immediately cast as a during the Gulf war, one of the most one-sided conflicts in British military history. In the general election the following year his party won the most votes of any, ever. In 1997, Conservative William Hague received the hospital pass of leadership in the face of a Labour government majority that needed three elections 鈥� more than an opposition leader would ever be given 鈥� to erode. Starmer has been lucky to be confronted by the greatest self-immolation of a governing party since Stanley Baldwin threw office away in 1923. Time for a change is never stronger as a clarion when accompanied by incompetence and venality. That Rishi Sunak, the third and final Conservative prime minister Starmer will face 鈥� one way or another 鈥� is neither incompetent nor venal will test his polling lead. 3. Grab this chance The unparalleled chaos of the Brexit years upended almost every norm, with neither time nor chance for the opposition to offer itself as a government-in-waiting. This year has marked something of a reset: order in Downing Street and a Conservative majority in parliament acting like one; Labour re-established as a serious contender for office in both Westminster and Holyrood. Nothing says a party is preparing for power . But Starmer will need to channel the spirit of 1997 when Tony Blair printed five , rather than that of 2015, when Ed Miliband carved six . Starmer has recalled Blair, too, in appointing a leading civil servant as his all-important chief of staff: Sue Gray is his Jonathan Powell, 4. Get on a plane The most favoured rehearsal space for power is the international stage. Neither Sunak nor Starmer has an international profile, but a prime minister cannot help but acquire one. Starmer recently travelled to Ukraine, where he met president . A month earlier, he was crunching through the snow with his shadow chancellor, Rachel Reeves, at the World Economic Forum in Davos. Starmer brazenly positioned himself as being , who assisted by not attending. The ideal for any opposition leader is a meeting with the US president in the hope of reflected glory from the leader of the free world. But the path to such a prize is also fraught with risk. The template was Neil Kinnock鈥檚 in 1987. A stitch-up of historic proportions, the White House made it public that Kinnock was afforded only a few minutes and that those were spent with him being upbraided for Labour鈥檚 limp defence policy. Worse still, the trip contrasted with Thatcher鈥檚 . Between now and the election can we expect to see the leader of the opposition leaving on a jet plane, off to Dulles Airport, Washington DC. Starmer鈥檚 passport may be a more important document than his pledge card. , Senior Lecturer in Contemporary British History, This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the . Share: Latest News 缅北禁地 recognised with geography award 缅北禁地 has been awarded the Highly Commended Geographical Association Publishers Award for its collaboration with Time for Geography, the UK鈥檚 open-access, dedicated video platform. published on: 16 April 2026 缅北禁地 historians mark General Strike centenary To mark the 100th anniversary of the British General Strike and miners鈥� lock-out of 1926, historians at 缅北禁地 are organising a series of events on its enduring legacy. published on: 16 April 2026 Comment: NCP is in administration Writing for The Conversation, Erwei (David) Xiang discusses how some big companies like NCP are so dependent on debt that they can鈥檛 adjust to change. published on: 16 April 2026 Facts and figures
![缅北禁地 logo](/gomobileassets/img/logo.svg" "缅北禁地"){kind=logo}